A Comparative Overview on the European Microstates Constitutionalism

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Department of Law, University of Venice, Venice, Italy

Abstract

The European microstates offer a notable lesson for both constitutional law and, generally speaking, the theory of state. The article analyzes this typology of state with a comparative method about constitutionalism of them. Indeed, in the 19th century, the concept of state was related, according to these disciplines and Hegel’s thought, not only to power, i.e. state power itself but also to “outward power”, that is authority at the international level. It is well known that our understanding of state power has changed since then. But, if a key factor in guaranteeing independence at the international level occurred to be might rather than power, something microstates are not familiar with. The result of the contribution is that European microstates teach us a precious lesson: the state is not only a question of power but also of might, the last one understood as the power to perform at the international level. 

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Andriamananjara S & Schiff M, ‘Regional Groupings among Microstates’, (1998), Washington: World Bank
  2. E, ‘Micro Remote Islands: Land of Freedom or Land of Despotism?’, (2020), 2 Pólemos
  3. Bertolini E, ‘The Constitutional Identity of European Micro States and the Continental Integration Mechanisms. The Influence of the Diminutive Size’, (2020), 2 ICL Journal 133
  4. Chabal P & Green T (eds), Guinea-Bissau: Micro-state to Narco-state, (London: Hurst & Company 2016)
  5. De Vendeuil, ‘L’industrialisation des micro-états européens: Liechtenstein, Monaco, Andorre’, (1983) Problemes economiques, 29
  6. Dommen E & Hein P, States, Microstates and Islands, (London: Croom Helm 1985)
  7. Dumienski Z, ‘Microstates as modern protected states: towards a new definition of micro-statehood’, (2014), Centre for Small State Studies, Institute of International Affairs, 1
  8. Duursma J, Self-determination, Statehood and International Relations of Micro-states: the Cases of Liechtenstein, San Marino, Monaco, Andorra and the Vatican City, (Leiden: University of Leiden 1994)
  9. Duursma J, ‘Fragmentation and the International Relations of Micro-states: Self-determination and Statehood’, (1996), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 976
  10. Guarino, La nozione di microstato nel diritto internazionale e nell’ordinamento internazionale, (1 Diritto e giurisprudenza, 1971)
  11. Guidi G (ed), Un collegio garante della costituzionalità delle norme in San Marino, (Rimini: Maggioli 2000).
  12. Guidi G (ed), Piccolo Stato, Costituzione e connessioni internazionali, (Turin: Giappichelli, 2003)
  13. Häberle P, ‘Federalismo, regionalismo e piccoli Stati in Europa’, (1994). In: Zagrebelsky (ed), Il federalismo e la democrazia europea, Rome: NIS, 78 ff
  14. Łukaszewski M, ‘Research on European Microstates in Social Science. Selected Methodological and Definitional Problems’, (2011), (1) Ad Alta Journal of Interdisciplinary Research, 74.
  15. Mazza R, ‘Microstati e principio di eguaglianza nella riflessione sulla membership del Liechtenstein all’ONU’, (2011). In: Vassalli di Dachenhausen (ed), Atti del Convegno in memoria di Luigi Sico: il contributo di Luigi Sico agli studi di diritto internazionale e di diritto dell’Unione europea, Naples: Editoriale Scientifica, 387
  16. Mazza R, Microstati e Nazioni Unite, (Naples: Editoriale Scientifica 2012)
  17. Mazzotti M, Il Drago e il Titano: i rapporti tra la Cina e un microstato europeo: dall’apertura delle relazioni diplomatiche ai nostri giorni, (San Marino: AIEP 2006)
  18. Morganti (ed.), Europa: il ritorno dei piccoli stati: autonomie, piccole patrie, processi di sussidiarietà, (Rimini: Il cerchio 2012)
  19. Musco S, I microstati nel sistema internazionale: considerazioni politiche e strategie di sopravvivenza, (Perugia: Morlacchi 2015)
  20. Stabile P, ‘La cittadinanza nei piccoli stati europei. Profili di diritto comparato e internazionale’, (2005) 4 Studi urbinati, 615
  21. Toso F, Frammenti d’Europa, (Milan: Giuffré, 1996)
  22. Valls, 1993. La nova constituciò d’Andorra, Andorra La Vella: Premsa Andorrana.
  23. Veenendaal W (ed), ‘Politics and Democracy in Microstates: a Comparative Analysis of the Effects of Size on Contestation and Inclusiveness’, (2013), Vol. 8, No. 2, Island Studies Journal, 321
  24. Vilar, Vers un nouveau statut juridique des vallées d’Andorre: la réforme constitutionnelle du 15 janvier 1981, (1984-1985), Aix-en-Provence: Mémoire I.E.P
  25. Viñas Farré, ‘La ley sobre la nacionalid andorrana. Repercusión de la sentencia del Tribunal constitucional del 15 de marzo de 1994’, (1996), Revista jurídica de Catalunya, 1057
Iranian Journal of International and Comparative Law
Volume 1, Issue 1
January 2023
Pages 175-182

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics