Renewable Energy Investment Incentives: The Approach of International Investment Agreements

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor, China Middle East Studies Institute, Shanghai International Studies University, Shanghai, China

2 PhD Graduate of International Law, Department of International Law, Faculty of Law, University of Qom, Qom, Iran

Abstract

Today the world is tackling climate change and simultaneously needs to overcome growing energy security challenges. The transition to renewable energy is known as the key strategy for reducing carbon emissions and ensuring energy security. However, not all countries access the required finance and technologies to successfully and sustainably deploy renewable energy projects. Therefore, they seek to attract foreign investment and technology. A growing number of governments are adopting incentives to compete in this field and create a more favorable investment atmosphere. The granting of investment incentives lies within the realm of national legislation which is susceptible to revocation by the host States. This exposes foreign investors to several risks as no State is bound by its unilateral commitments and the change or withdrawal of pro-foreign investment policies by the host States is a mere exercise of their sovereignty. As International Investment Agreements (IIAs) were primarily drafted to promote and protect cross-border investments against unfair and discriminatory treatments, it is interesting to know their current approach to investment incentives and assess its implications for renewable energy investments. Adopting a qualitative approach, this research aims to clarify this issue by defining investment incentives and shedding new light on the relevant clauses in IIAs that can better contribute to the protection of renewable energy investors’ interests. Findings suggest that harmonizing investment incentives by including them in IIAs has not been on the agenda so far and IIAs seldom contain renewable energy-related incentive provisions. Therefore, this research points out the relevant provisions that can better accommodate the renewable energy investment needs.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Arvizu D et al., ‘Technical Summary’ in O Edenhofer and others (eds), Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation: Special Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (Cambridge University Press 2012).
  2. Bellak C and Leibrecht M, ‘The Use of Investment Incentives: The Cases of R&D-Related Incentives and International Investment Agreements’ in A T Tavares-Lehmann and others (eds), Rethinking Investment Incentives: Trends and Policy Options (Columbia University Press 2016).
  3. Borlini L and Silingardi S, ‘The Foundations of International Economic Order in the Age of State Capitalism’ in P Delimatsis, G Dimitropoulos and A Gourgourinis (eds), State Capitalism and International Investment Law (Hart Publishing 2023).
  4. Brauch MD, ‘Reforming International Investment Law for Climate Change Goals’ in M Mehling and H Asselt (eds), Research Handbook on Climate Finance and Investment Law (Edward Elgar Publishing forthcoming 2023).
  5. Crockett A, ‘Stabilisation Clauses and Sustainable Development: Drafting for the Future’ in C Brown and K Miles (eds), Evolution in Investment Treaty Law and Arbitration (Cambridge University Press 2011).
  6. Dromgool T and Enguix DY, ‘The Fair and Equitable Treatment Standard and Revocation of Feed-in Tariffs: Foreign Renewable Energy Investments in Crisis-Struck Spain’ in Volker Mauerhofer (ed), Legal Aspects of Sustainable Development (Springer 2016).
  7. Frey C, ‘Tackling Climate Change Through the Elimination of Trade Barriers for Low-Carbon Goods: Multilateral, Plurilateral and Regional Approaches’ in V Mauerhofer (ed), Legal Aspects of Sustainable Development: Horizontal and Sectorial Policy Issues (Springer 2016).
  8. Gagné J, Energy Technology Perspectives: Harnessing Electricity’s Potential (IEA Publications 2014).
  9. Gentry BS and Ronk J, ‘International Investment Agreements and Investments in Renewable Energy’ in Leslie Parker and others (eds), From Barriers to Opportunities: Renewable Energy Issues in Law and Policy (Forestry & Environmental Studies Publications Series 2007).
  10. Herdegen M, Principles of International Economic Law (Oxford University Press 2016).
  11. Lehr RL, ‘Public Policy Perspective: Regulatory Incentives to Support Grid Modernization’ in Lisa Schwartz (ed), Regulatory Incentives and Disincentives for Utility Investments in Grid Modernization: Future Electric Utility Regulation/Report No. 8 (Berkeley Lab 2017).
  12. Raikar S and Adamson S, Renewable Energy Finance: Theory and Practice (Academic Press 2019).
  13. Sasse JP, An Economic Analysis of Bilateral Investment Treaties (Gabler Verlag 2011).
  14. Sornarajah M, The International Law on Foreign Investment (Cambridge University Press 2021).
  15. Timofeyev IV and others, ‘Investment Disputes Involving the Renewable Energy Industry Under the Energy Charter Treaty’ in J W Rowley, D Bishop and G E Kaiser (eds), The Guide to Energy Arbitrations (Law Business Research 2020).
  1. Abdul Qadir S and others, ‘Incentives and Strategies for Financing the Renewable Energy Transition: A Review’ (2021) 7 Energy Reports 3590.
  2. Ahmad Z, ‘Conflicts of the SCM Agreement with LDCs Interests over Renewable Energy Incentives: Proposals for Reform’ (2015) 50(2) Foreign Trade Review 118.
  3. Alves EC and others, ‘From a Breeze to the Four Winds: A Panel Analysis of the International Diffusion of Renewable Energy Incentive Policies (2005–2015)’ (2019) 125 Energy Policy 317.
  4. Bennon M and Fukuyama F, ‘The Obsolescing Bargain Crosses the Belt and Road Initiative: Renegotiations on BRI Projects’ (2022) 32(2) Oxford Review of Economic Policy 278.
  5. Biggs J, ‘The Scope of Investors’ Legitimate Expectations under the FET Standard in the European Renewable Energy Cases’ (2021) 36(1) ICSID Review 99.
  6. Gourgourinis A, ‘Domestic Investment Incentives in International Trade Law’ (2023) 22(1) World Trade Review 35.
  7. Grippa P, Schmittmann J and Suntheim F, ‘Climate Change and Financial Risk: Central Banks and Financial Regulators Are Starting to Factor in Climate Change’ (2019) 56(4) Finance and Development 26.
  8. Haas R and others, ‘A Historical Review of Promotion Strategies for Electricity from Renewable Energy Sources in EU Countries’ (2011) 15(2) Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 1003.
  9. Komendantova N, Schinkoa T and Patt A, ‘De-risking Policies as a Substantial Determinant of Climate Change Mitigation Costs in Developing Countries: Case Study of the Middle East and North African Region’ (2019) 127(c) Energy Policy 404.
  10. Leal-Arcas R, ‘The Multilateralization of International Investment Law’ (2009) 35(1) North Carolina JILCR 33.
  11. Melović B and Ćirović D, ‘Analysis of Financial Incentives as an Instrument of Renewable Energy Sources Management in Montenegro’ (2020) 157(04001) E3S Web of Conferences 1.
  12. Meyer T, ‘Free Trade, Fair Trade, and Selective Enforcement’ (2018) 118 Columbia Law Review 491.
  13. Miljenić O, ‘Energy Charter Treaty – Standards of Investment Protection’ (2018) 24(83) Croatian International Relations Review 52.
  14. Ozcan M, ‘Assessment of Renewable Energy Incentive System from Investors' Perspective’ (2014) 71 Renewable Energy 425.
  15. Pinto FV and Granadeiro J, ‘Round-up of Arbitrations in the Renewable Energy Sector: Lessons for Portugal’ (2019) 6(2) e-Pública 73.
  16. Poudineh R, Sen A and Fattouh B, ‘Advancing Renewable Energy in Resource-Rich Economies of the MENA’ (2018) 123 Renewable Energy 135.
  17. Sarti B, ‘Policies for the Deployment of Renewable Energies: An Overview’ (2018) 62 Social Impact Research Experience (SIRE) 1.
  18. Staats JL and Biglaiser G, ‘The Effects of Judicial Strength and Rule of Law on Portfolio Investment in the Developing World’ (2011) 92(3) Social Science Quarterly 609.
  19. Tryndina N and others, ‘Renewable Energy Incentives on the Road to Sustainable Development During Climate Change: A Review’ (2022) 10 Frontiers in Environmental Science 1.
  20. Walde TW, ‘The "Umbrella" Clause in Investment Arbitration: A Comment on Original Intentions and Recent Cases’ (2005) 6(2) Journal of World Investment & Trade 183.
  21. Wang Q, ‘Effective Policies for Renewable Energy - The Example of China's Wind Power - Lessons for China's Photovoltaic Power’ (2010) 14(2) Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 702.
  22. Zakaria SU et al., ‘Public Awareness Analysis on Renewable Energy in Malaysia’ (2019) 268 IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1.
  23. Zannoni D, ‘The Legitimate Expectation of Regulatory Stability under the Energy Charter Treaty’ (2020) 33(2) Leiden Journal of International Law 451.
  24. Zhao Z, Chen Y and Chang R, ‘How to Stimulate Renewable Energy Power Generation Effectively? - China's Incentive Approaches and Lessons’ (2016) 92 Renewable Energy 147.
  1. Agreement between China and Kuwait for the Promotion and Protection of Investments(signed 23 November 1985, entered into force 24 December 1986).
  2. Agreement between Japan and Georgia for the Liberalisation, Promotion and Protection of Investment (signed 29 January 2021, entered into force 23 July 2021) (‘Japan-Georgia BIT’).
  3. Agreement for the Promotion and Protection of Investment between Japan and Kenya, No. 55787 (signed 28 August 2016, entered into force 14 September 2017) (‘Japan-Kenya BIT’).
  4. Agreement Oman and Hungary for the Promotion and Reciprocal Protection of Investments(signed 2 February 2022, entered into force 24 October 2022).
  5. Agreement on Promotion, Protection and Guarantee of Investments among Member States of the Organization of the Islamic Conference (adopted 5 June 1981, entered into force 23 September 1986).
  6. Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (entered into force 1 January 1995) 1869 UNTS 14 (‘SCM’).
  7. ECOWAS Common Investment Code (opened for signature 22 December 2019, entered into force 22 December 2019).
  8. Enhanced Partnership and Cooperation Agreement between the European Union and the Republic of Kazakhstan (opened for signature 21 December 2015, entered into force 1 March 2020) (‘EU-Kazakhstan EPCA’).
  9. European Parliament, Directive EU2018/2001 of 11 December 2018 on the Promotion of the Use of Energy from Renewable Sources (recast), [2018] OJ L328/82, 11/12/2018.
  10. Free Trade Agreement between the Arab Republic of Egypt and the EFTA States (opened for signature 27 April 2007, entered into force 1 September 2008).
  11. Interim Agreement Establishing an Economic Partnership Agreement between the United Kingdom and the Republic of Cameroon (signed 9 March 2021, entered into force 19 July 2021) (‘Cameroon - UK EPA’).
  12. Investment Cooperation and Facilitation Treaty between Brazil and India (signed 25 January 2020, not yet in force) (‘Brazil-India BIT’).
  13. Model Text for the Indian Bilateral Investment Treaty (2015).
  14. Political, Free Trade and Strategic Partnership Agreement between the UK and Ukraine(signed 8 October 2020, entered into force 1 January 2021).
  15. The Energy Charter Treaty (opened for signature 17 December 1994, entered into force 16 April 1998) (‘ECT’) 2080 UNTS 100.
  16. Trade and Cooperation Agreement between the EU and the UK (opened for signature 30 December 2020, entered into force 1 May 2021).
  17. Treaty Establishing the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (opened for signature 5 November 1993, entered into force 8 December 1994) (‘COMESA’).
  18. Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (adopted 23 May 1969, entered into force 27 January 1980) 1155 UNTS 331.
  1. AES Solar and others (PV Investors) v The Kingdom of Spain (Final Award) (PCA Case No. 2012-14, 28 February 2020).
  2. Antaris Solar GmbH and Dr Michael Gode v Czech Republic (PCA, Case No. 2014-01, 8 May 2013).
  3. Azurix Corp v The Argentine Republic (Award) (ICSID Case No ARB/01/12, 14 July 2006).
  4. BayWa r.e. Renewable Energy GmbH and BayWa r.e. Asset Holding GmbH v Kingdom of Spain(ICSID Case No. ARB/15/16, 16 April 2015).
  5. Biwater Gauff (Tanzania) Ltd v United Republic of Tanzania (Award) (ICSID Case No. ARB/05/22, 24 July 2008).
  6. Cairn Energy PLC and Cairn UK Holdings Limited v The Republic of India (Final Award) (PCA Case No. 2016-07, 21 December 2020).
  7. Charanne B.V. and Construction Investments S.A.R.L. v Spain (Final Award) (SCC Case No. 062/2012, 21 January 2016).
  8. Eiser Infrastructure Limited and Energía Solar Luxembourg S.à r.l. v Kingdom of Spain (Award) (ICSID Case No. ARB/13/36, 4 May 2017).
  9. Eiser Infrastructure Limited and Energía Solar Luxembourg S.à r.l. v Kingdom of Spain (ICSID Case No. ARB/13/36, 23 December 2013).
  10. Electrabel S.A. v The Republic of Hungary (Decision on Jurisdiction, Applicable Law and Liability) (ICSID Case No. ARB/07/19, 30 November 2012).
  11. ESPF Beteiligungs GmbH, ESPF Nr. 2 Austria Beteiligungs GmbH, and InfraClass Energie 5 GmbH & Co. KG v Italian Republic (ICSID Case No. ARB/16/5, 8 March 2016).
  12. Hulley Enterprises Ltd. v Russian Federation (Final Award) (PCA Case No. 2005-03/AA226, 18 July 2014).
  13. InfraRed Environmental Infrastructure GP Limited and others v Kingdom of Spain (Award) (ICSID Case No. ARB/14/12, 2 August 2019).
  14. Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.r.l. and Energia Termosolar B.V. v Kingdom of Spain(ICSID Case No. ARB/13/31, 29 October 2013).
  15. Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.rl and Energia Termosolar BV v Kingdom of Spain(Award) (ICSID Case No. ARB/13/31, 15 June 2018).
  16. Masdar Solar & Wind Cooperatief U.A. v Kingdom of Spain (Award) (ICSID Case No. ARB/14/1, 16 May 2018).
  17. National Grid Public Limited Company v The Argentine Republic (Award) (UNCITRAL Case No. 1:09-cv-00248-RBW, 3 November 2008).
  18. Noble Ventures, Inc. v Romania (Award) (ICSID, Case No ARB/01/11, 12 October 2005).
  19. Occidental Exploration and Production Company v Republic of Ecuador (I) (Award) (LCIA Case No UN3467, 1 July 2004).
  20. Quasar de Valores SICAV S.A., Orgor de Valores SICAV S.A., GBI 9000 SICAV S.A. and ALOS 34 S.L. v. The Russian Federation (Award) (SCC Case No. 24/2007, 20 July 2012).
  21. RREEF Infrastructure (G.P.) Limited and RREEF Pan-European Infrastructure Two Lux S.à r.l. v Kingdom of Spain (ICSID Case No. ARB/13/30, 23 November 2013).
  22. Saluka Investments BV v Czech Republic (Partial Award) (PCA, Case No. 2001-04, 17 March 2006).
  23. Siemens AG v The Argentine Republic (Award) (ICSID Case No ARB/02/8, 17 January 2007).
  24. SolEs Badajoz GmbH v Kingdom of Spain (Award) (ICSID Case No. ARB/15/38, 31 July 2019).
  25. Yukos Universal Limited (Isle of Man) v The Russian Federation (Final Award) (PCA, Case No 2005-4/AA 227, 18 July 2014).
  1. Damuri YR and Atje R, Investment Incentives for Renewable Energy: Case Study of Indonesia (The International Institute for Sustainable Development 2013).
  2. Eberhard A and others, Directions in Development, Energy and Mining: Independent Power Projects in Sub-Saharan Africa - Lessons from Five Key Countries (World Bank Group 2016).
  3. Energy Charter Secretariat, Special Paper Series: Handbook on General Provisions Applicable to Investment Agreements in the Energy Sector (ECS 2017).
  4. International Energy Agency, Perspectives for the Energy Transition – Investment Needs for a Low Carbon Energy System (IEA/IRENA 2017).
  5. James S, Tax and Non-Tax Incentives and Investments: Evidence and Policy Implications (World Bank Group 2014).
  6. Johnson L and Toledano P, Investment Incentives: A Survey of Policies and Approaches for Sustainable Investment (Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment 2022).
  7. OECD, Governing Regional Development Policy: The Use of Performance Indicators (OECD Publishing 2009).
  8. OECD, Overcoming Barriers to International Investment in Clean Energy, Green Finance and Investment (OECD Publishing 2015).
  9. OECD, Public Sector Transparency and the International Investor (OECD Publications 2003).
  10. REN21, ‘Renewables 2017 Global Status Report’ (REN21 Secretariat, 2017) https://www.ren21.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/GSR2017_Full-Report_English.pdf accessed 20 June 2023.
  11. UNCTAD, Incentives: Series on Issues in International Investment Agreements (United Nations Publication 2004).
  12. UNCTAD, Investment Promotion Provisions in International Investment Agreements (United Nations Publication 2008).
  13. UNCTAD, State Contracts: Series on Issues in International Investment Agreements (United Nations Publication 2004).
  14. UNCTAD, World Investment Report 2022: International Tax Reforms and Sustainable Investment(United Nations Publication 2022).
  15. UNEP, The Emissions Gap Report 2018 (United Nations Environment Programme 2018).
  16. Wilke M, Feed-in Tariffs for Renewable Energy and WTO Subsidy Rules: An Initial Legal Review(International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development 2011).
  17. WTO, Canada-Certain Measures Affecting the Renewable Energy Generation Sector- Report of the Appellate Body, WT/DS412/AB/R (6 May 2013).
  18. WTO, Canada-Measures Relating to the Feed-in Tariff Program- Report of the Appellate Body, WT/DS426/AB/R (6 May 2013).
  19. Yamaguchi S and Dellink R, Greening Regional Trade Agreements on Investment (OECD Publications 2020).
  1. International Trademark Association, ‘IP in Outer Space: The Next Frontier’ https://www.inta.org/perspectives/features/ip-in-outer-space-the-next-frontier accessed 22 July 2023.
  2. Investment Policy Hub, ‘Investment Dispute Settlement Navigator’ https://investmentpolicy.unctad.org/investment-dispute-settlement/advanced-search accessed 20 May 2023.
  3. Japan Bank for International Cooperation, ‘Overseas Investment Loans’ (JBIC) https://www.jbic.go.jp/en/support-menu/investment.html accessed 20 March 2023.
  4. Kenneth O and Antolín FA, ‘Taxation Exclusions’ (Jus Mundi, 6 September 2022) https://jusmundi.com/en/document/publication/en-taxation-exclusions# accessed 20 January 2023.
  5. Lakeh HK, ‘What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Renewable Energy?’ (20 May 2022) https://www.greenmatch.co.uk/blog/2021/09/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-renewable-energyaccessed 25 June 2023.
  6. Runyon J, ‘IEA: Feed-in Tariff Not a Subsidy, But Tax Credits Are’ (Renewable Energy World, 11 January 2013) https://www.renewableenergyworld.com/solar/iea-feed-in-tariff-not-a-subsidy-but-tax-credits-are/ accessed 24 May 2023.
  7. The University of Calgary, ‘Fiscal Incentives’ (Energy Education) https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Fiscal_incentive#cite_note-IPCC_SRREN-2 accessed 10 May 2023.
  8. Union of Concerned Scientists, ‘Benefits of Renewable Energy Use’ (20 December 2017) https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/benefits-renewable-energy-use accessed 20 June 2023.

 

Iranian Journal of International and Comparative Law
Volume 2, Issue 1
June 2024
Pages 88-119

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics