A Comparative Analysis of the General Theory of Arsh in Islamic Jurisprudence and the Principle of Price Reduction in the CISG

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Private Law, Qom Osool-e ddin College, Qom, Iran.

10.22091/ijicl.2024.8990.1053

Abstract

The examination of traditional legal institutions is a prudent approach to ensure effective contractual remedies. "Arsh" is one such institution that predominantly arises in relation to the option of defect. This paper aims to review the perspectives of Islamic legal scholars on Arsh in order to establish it as a general theory. However, it should be noted that this review does not propose a structural alteration in the nature of Arsh; rather, it intends to conduct a jurisprudential inquiry into the subject-matter. With regard to the nature of the general theory of Arsh, it can be categorized as a form of damages and compensation resulting from a breach of contract and contractual liability. In such cases, it aligns with the relevant legal principles. The basis of damages in the general theory of Arsh also exhibits a dual nature. While it is rooted in contractual compensation, if such compensation cannot be adequately provided, civil and obligatory liability may be invoked. One of the well-established legal-historical principles in the Civil Law system is the rule of Price Reduction, which bears resemblance to the institution of Arsh (i.e., the financial difference between a defective and non-defective item that is compensated to the customer) in the Islamic legal system. It is noteworthy that the foundation of Price Reduction lies in the principle of Commutative Justice, which serves as the basis for contractual liability in the realm of contract law.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Abdipourfard E, Saghafi A, 'Arsh of Condition' (2008) No. 19 Journal of jurisprudence and law 63
AbuAta M, Shamsullahi A, 'The Analysis of Basis and the Legal Nature of Arsh' (2002) 3rd Year No. 5 Islamic Jurisprudence and Law Studies 9
Akhund Khorasani M.K, Hashiye Al-Makaseb (Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance 1986)
Allameh Helli H, Ershad al-Ezhan, vol. 1 (Qom: Islamic Publishing 1990)
Ameli M (Shahid Aval), Al-Qawaed al-Fawaed, vol. 2 (Qum: Maktabe al-Mufid, no date)
Ameli Z (Shahid Sani) Rozeh al-Behayee, vol. 3 (Dar al-'Alam al-Islami Institute 1983)
Ameli Z (Shahid Sani), Masalak al-Afham, 5th edition (Institute of al-Maref al-Eslami 1994)
Bariklou A, Beigzadeh S, 'Principle of Reduction of Price- Comparative Study in the International Sale Convention' (2011) Vol.15 No.3 Imamiyya Jurisprudence and Iranian Law- Comparative Law Studies of Tarbiat Modares University 57
Behroozizad H.R, 'The nature of blood money: Penalty or Compensation' (2006) No.60 Dadresi 50
Bergsten E, Anthony M.J, 'The Remedy of Reduction of Price', available at: https://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/bergsten.html.
Bojnourdi S.M.H, al-Qawaed al-Fiqh, vol. 4 (Qom: al-Hadi Publication 1998)
Bonell B, Commentary on the International Sales Law, (Milan: Giuffrè 1987)
Boroujerdi M.T, A narrative of the discussions of Aqa Zia Araghi, Nahaya al-Afkar (Nashr al-Islami 1992)
Emami S.H, Civil Rights, vol. 1 (publications of Islamiyah Bookstore 1998)
Firouzabadi M, Al-Qamous Mohit, vol. 2 (Beirut: Dar al-Ahya al-Tarath al-Arabi 1992)
Fumi A, al-Mesbah al-Monir (Qom: Institute of al-Hijra 1987)
Horr Ameli M, Wasael al-Shia, vol. 12 (Qom: Al-al-Bait Institution 1990)
Hosseini Maraghi M.F, al-Anawin al-Faqh, vol. 1 (Institute of Islamic Publication of Society of Teachers in the Seminary of Qom 1997)
Hosseini Sistani S.A, Rule of no-harm (the Grand Ayatullah Sistani)- The First Issue (Qom: The Grand Ayatullah Seyyed Ali Hosseini Sistani Publications 1994)
Ibn Babuye F.R, al-Mu'tmer al-'Alami Lel-Imam al-Reza (Mashhad 1986)
Ibn Manzur F, Lissan al-Arab, vol. 1 (Beirut: Dar al-Ahya al-Tarath al-Arabi 1988)
Jafari Langroudi M.J, al-Fareq (Tehran: Ganj Danesh Publications 2003)
Jafari Langroudi M.J, The General Philosophy of Law Based on the Originality of Practice (Tehran: Ganj Danesh Publications 2002)
Katouzian N, 'Contractual Freedom Constraints Based on Consumer Protection' (2008) No.3 Law Quarterly Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science 327
Katouzian N, Civil responsibility from manufacturing defect (Tehran University publications 2011)
Katouzian N, General rules of contracts, vol. 3, 5 (Joint Stock Company of Publication 2015)
Katouzian N, Non-contractual requirements (Obligatory and civil liability), vol. 1 (Tehran: Tehran University Press 2003)
Katouzin N, Certain contracts, vol. 1 (Joint-Stock Company of Publication 1997)
Kazemi Khorasani M.A, Explanations of the discussion of Principles of Mirza Na'ini- Fawayed al-Osul, vol. 4 (Qom: al-Eslami Publishing 1986)
Lotfi A, Causes of obligatory guaranty (Tehran: Majd Publications 2000)
Lotfi A, Sale contract (Tehran: Khorsandi 2009)
Mamqani A, Manhaj al-Muttaqin Fi al-Fiqh Imamiyya al-Haq wa al-Yaghi (Najaf: lithography publishing 1969)
Mamqani A, Nahaya al-Maqal (Tehran: Lithography 1965)
Moghadas Ardebili A, Assembly of al-Faydeh wa al-Burhan, vol. 8 (Qom: Al-Nashr al-Islami-Qom Institute 1987)
Mohaghegh Damad S.M, The Rules of Civil Jurisprudence (Tehran: Islamic Sciences Publishing Center 2006)
Mohaghegh Helli N.D.J, Sharaye al-Islam, vol. 2 (Najaf: al-Adab 2010)
Mohaghegh Isfahani M.H, Hashiye, al-Makaseb, vol. 4, 5 (Qom: Dar-al-Mustafi Le-Ahya al-tarath 2002)
Mohaghegh Korki A, Jamne al-Maghased, vol. 4 (Qom: Al-al-Beyt Le-Ahya al-Tarath Institute 1988)
Moosavi Khomeini S.R, Sale, vol. 5 (Qom: Institute of al-Nashr al-Islami 1990)
Mousavi Khoiy S.A, by Mohammad Ali Tohidi, Mesbah al-Feghaha, vol. 7 (Qom: Institute of Ansarian 1997)
Mousavi Khomeini S.R, Tahrir al-Wasile, vol. 1 (Qom: al-Nashr al-Islami 1996)
Muria Tunon A, 'The Actio Arsh and Sales of Goods Between Mexico and the U.S: An Analysis of the Remedy of Price in the UN Sales Convention, CISG Article 50, and Its Civil Law Antecedents' (1998) available at: <www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/muria.html>.
Najafi M.H, Jawahar al-Klamah, vols. 23 & 37 (Tehran: Dar al-Kotob al-Eslamiye 1988)
Piliounis PA, 'The Remedies of Specific Performance, Price Reduction, and Additional Time (Nachfrist) under the CISG: Are These Worthwhile Changes or Additions to English Sales Law?' available at: https://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/piliounis.html.
Sadr S.M.B, Dorus Fi Elm al-Osul, vol. 1 (Beirut: Dar-al-Montazer 1987)
Sadr S.M.B, Bihus Fi Elm al-Osul, vol. 5 (Center of al-Ghadir Lel-Dorasat al-Islami 1996)
Safaei S.H, Primary Course of Civil Liberty, vol. 2 (Tehran: Nashr al-Mizan 2003)
Saw E, 'End of contractual liability- translation of Hossein Norouzi' (2001) No.35 Journal of Legal Justice 109
Schlechtriem S.P, Commentary on the UN Convention on the International Sale of Goods (CISG), (Fourth Edition, Oxford University Press 2016)
Sheikh Mufid M, al-Maqnah (Qom: Institute of al-Nashr al-Islami 1990)
Shekari R, The description and translation of the texts of the jurisprudence of sale and options (Tehran: Keshavarz Publishing 2003)
Sobhani Tabrizi J, al-Mukhtar Fi Ahkam al-Khiyar- Derase Mabsute Fi al-Khiyar wa Ahkam wa al-Shorut wa al-Naghd wa al-Nasiye wa al-Ghabz (Qum: al-Emam al-Sadeq 2002)
Sondahel E, 'Understanding the Remedy of Price Reduction – A Means to Fostering a More Uniform Application of the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods' available at: http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/sondahl.html.
Tabataba'i Yazdi S.M.K, Hashiye al-Makaseb, vol. 3 (Qom: Dar al-Mustafi Le-Ahya al-Tarath 2002)
'UNCITRAL Digest of Case Law on the United Nations Convention on the International Sale of Goods, Digest of Article 50 Case Law, para 3' available at: http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/text/digest-2012-50.html.
Vahid Behbahani M.B, Hashiye Majma al-Fayede al-Borhan (Qom: Institute of Allameh Vahid Behbahani 2000)
Younes M, Kashf al-Qanaah, vol. 2 (Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Elmiye).
Zakaria A, Moghabis al-Loghah, vol. 1 (School of al-Alam al-Eslami Qom 1984)
Zehni Tehrani M.J, Expression of al-Morad, Persian Description on the principles of Jurisprudance (Mozaffar) vol. 3 (Ganjine Zehni 2009)
Ziegel J.S, 'in Report to the Uniform Law Conference of Canada on Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods' (1981) available at: http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/text/ziegel50.html.e.
Zimmerman R, The Law of Obligations (Clarendon Press Publication 1996)
Iranian Journal of International and Comparative Law
Volume 1, Issue 2
July 2023
Pages 207-225

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics