Floor Crossing in the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh: A Comparative Legal Perspective

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Lecturer in Business Law, Faculty of Business, Curtin University Malaysia

2 Assistant Professor of Law, American International University- Bangladesh (AIUB), Kuratoli, Bangladesh

Abstract

Whether floor crossing is democratic or undemocratic under Article 70 of the Bangladeshi Constitution is a significant question. The major goal of this rule is to prevent Members of Parliament (MPs) from voting against their party, lest their seats in Parliament be vacated. However, this article's violation of the Members of Parliament's (MPs') right to free speech is a major matter for worry, as it violates their fundamental rights. The primary purpose of this study is to examine the existing floor crossing law to determine whether or not it constitutes a breach of fundamental rights as embodied in the Bangladeshi Constitution, and to identify the gaps prevalent in the provision regulating floor crossing. This paper employs the doctrinal research methodology, utilizing journal articles, textbooks, academic databases, and online resources. In this study, we've attempted to introduce the provisions of floor crossing and describe it with historical context, Article 70 of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, and provisions in other nations such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and India. We have reviewed the rationale for barring floor crossing and why this provision will not be altered. We have also reviewed a recent incidence involving floor crossing and a case study that constructively critiques the regulation. We have determined that floor crossing is abandoning one's party in Parliament to vote for the opposing party during the bill's voting or passage, and we have provided recommendations to fix this issue and make the provision of floor crossing acceptable for the benefit of our people.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Horn G, Crossing the Floor: Reg Prentice and the Crisis of British Social Democracy (2016) 1-256.
Al Faruque A, ‘Role of Parliament in Ensuring Democratic Accountability in Bangladesh: Setting the Agenda for a Strengthened Parliamentary System’ in The Constitutional Law of Bangladesh: Progression and Transformation at its 50th Anniversary (Springer Nature Singapore 2023) 121-137.
Hossain K, ‘The Making of the Bangladesh Constitution’ in The Emergence of Bangladesh: Interdisciplinary Perspectives (Springer Nature Singapore 2022) 57-65.
Bari ME and Dey P, ‘The Anti-Defection Provision Contained in the Constitution of Bangladesh, 1972, and Its Adverse Impact on Parliamentary Democracy: A Case for Reform’ (2020) 37(3) Wisconsin International Law Journal 487.
Janda K, ‘Laws Against Party Switching, Defecting, or Floor-Crossing in National Parliaments’ in World Congress of the International Political Science Association (Santiago, Chile 2009) 12-16.
Karim SMT, ‘Is Anti-Floor Crossing Law in Bangladesh Contrary to the Spirit of the Constitution of Bangladesh? An Inquiry’ (2014) 4 Kathmandu School of Law Review 123.
Malebeswa TE, ‘Floor Crossing and Elective Office: Freedom of Choice or Betrayal of Trust?—The Case of Botswana’ (2020) 28 University of Botswana Law Journal 81.
Rahman Z, ‘Democracy: Freedom of Speech and Floor-Crossing Interface’ (2010) 1 Northern University Journal of Law 24-38.
Smiles J, ‘Floor-Crossing: A Controversial Democratic Process’ (2007) 32(1) Journal for Contemporary History 130-148.
Hossain MM, ‘Critical Evaluation of the Article 70 of the Constitution of Bangladesh and Its Contravention with the Constitution’ (PhD Dissertation, East West University 2023).
Joubert LK, ‘The Mandate of Political Representatives with Special Reference to Floor Crossing: A Legal Historical Study’ (PhD Dissertation, University of South Africa 2006).
Alam MA, ‘Anti-Defection Law and Its Impact Over Constitutionalism in Bangladesh: An Analytical Study’ (2024) SSRN 4708257 https://ssrn.com/abstract=4708257 accessed September 20, 2024.
Iranian Journal of International and Comparative Law
Volume 2, Issue 1
June 2024
Pages 165-179

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics