Evidence and Burden of Proof in the Jurisprudence of the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal and Its Impact on Case B-1

Document Type : Original Article

Author

PhD in International Law, University of Tehran, Iran; Researcher at Strategic Studies Center of IRI Army, Iran

Abstract

In the case of “Iran’s Foreign Military Sales” (Case B-1), which encompasses six claims and a counterclaim, proceedings have continued for over four decades. A focal point in the process of filing numerous applications and the rulings issued in this case has consistently been the issue of evidence and the burden of proof. This qualitative research aims to address the fundamental question of the approaches taken by the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal  regarding evidence and the burden of proof, as well as the implications of these approaches on the adjudication of Case B-1. The findings indicate that the Tribunal, in each case, has adhered not only to general legal principles - such as ‘actori incumbit onus probandi’ -but also to the unique circumstances and specific conditions of each case, such as the accessibility of evidence, in determining the allocation of the burden of proof. As the parties strive to substantiate the credibility of their evidence before the Tribunal using general principles of international law, which are potentially recognized as applicable law by the Tribunal, they also seek to undermine the credibility of the opposing party’s evidence through various arguments. It is essential for Iran to enhance its precision in referencing the submitted documents and to clarify the technical dimensions, as well as to ensure compliance with the Tribunal’s standards in future rulings, in order to achieve its objectives in other ongoing cases.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Katouzian N, Proof and Evidence, Volume 1, General Rules of Proof, Admission, and Document (8th edn, Mizan Publications 2013).
Sādāt Meydānī S H, International Proceedings - International Court of Justice - Evidence in Litigation (Jangal Publication 2012).
Arab Chadegani R, 'Governing Law and Its Impact on the Foreign Military Sales (FMS) Case in the Iran-United States Claims Tribunal' (2019) 50(4) Quarterly Journal of Public Law Studies 1643.
Blackaby N, Partasides C, Redfern A and Hunter M, Redfern and Hunter International Arbitration (Oxford University Press 2015) 388.
Kazazi M, Burden of Proof and Related Issues (Kluwer Law International 1996).
Sandifer DV, Evidence Before International Tribunals (Foundation Press Inc. 1975).
Gibson CS and Drahozal CR, 'Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Precedent in Investor-State Arbitration' (2006) 23 Journal of International Arbitration 521-546, Suffolk University Law School Research Paper No. 07-15.
Avena and Other Mexican Nationals (Mexico v United States of America) (Judgment) [2004] ICJ Rep.
Corfu Channel Case (UK v Albania) (Judgment) [1949] ICJ Rep 4.
Pulp Mills on the River Uruguay (Argentina v Uruguay) (Judgment) [2010] ICJ Rep 14, para 163.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 1, Statement of Claim of Ministry of National Defense.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 1360 (Claim No. 2-3), Full Tribunal, Request and Exhibits of the United States for an Order Directing the Production of Documents and Suspending the Proceedings until Claimant.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 1551 (Claim No. 2-3), Full Tribunal, Order, 18 March 1998.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 1949, Counterclaim, Interlocutory Award No. ITL 83-B1-FT, 9 September 2004
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 199 (Claim No. 4), Full Tribunal, Order.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 308 (Claim No. 2-3), Full Tribunal, Order, 16 May 1984.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 593 (Claim No. 5), Full Tribunal, Award No. 370-B1-FT (16 June 1988).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 664 (Claim No. 2 & 3), Full Tribunal, Order.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal, Case B1, Doc. 860 (Claim No. 4), Full Tribunal, Partial Award on Agreed Terms No. 525-B1-FT (2 December 1991).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 11, Iran v United States (DEC 45-A20-FT) (10 July 1986).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 12, Austin Company v Mashine sazi Arak 294, para 31.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 12, Oil Field of Texas, Inc. v National Iranian Oil Company, Award No. 258-43-1 (8 October 1986).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 14, Ford Aerospace and Communications Corporation v Iran.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 15, SEDCO Inc. v Iran Marine Industrial Company.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 17, Iran National Airlines Co. v United States (B-8) (1987) AWD 333-B8-2.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 18, Lockheed Corporation v The Government of Iran, the Ministry of War and the Iranian Air Force (9 June 1988) AWD 367-829-2.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 19, Avco Corporation v Iran Aircraft Industries (1988) AWD 377-261-3, 200, 222-223.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 19, International Ore & Fertilizer Corporation v Razi Chemical Co. Ltd. AWD No. 351-486-3 (1988) (Brower, J dissenting).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 19, Malek v Iran (Also Reza Saeed Malek v Iran).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 20, Houston Contracting Co. v National Iranian Oil Co. (1988) AWD 378-173-3.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 20, Houston Contracting Co. v Iran.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 22, Seismograph Service Corp. v National Iranian Oil Co. AWD 420-443-3 (31 March 1989) 55-56, para 199.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 23, Rockwell International Systems, Inc. v The Ministry of National Defence, Award No. 438-430-1 (5 September 1989).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 26, Combustion Engineering, Inc. v Iran, Award No. 506-308-2 (18 February 1991).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 27, Levitt v Iran (Case No. 210) 179, para 107.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 28, Collins Systems Int'l, Inc. v Navy of the Islamic Republic of Iran, AWD 526-431-2.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 29, Kaysons International v Iran, Award No. 548-367-2 (28 June 1993).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 31, Dadras International v Iran, Award No. 567-213, 215-3 (7 November 1995).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 4, CMI International v Ministry of Roads and Transport of the Islamic Republic of Iran, AWD 99-245-2 (27 December 1983).
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 7, R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company v Iran 190.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 8, DIC of Delaware, Inc. v Tehran Redevelopment Corp. (1985) AWD 176-255-3.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 9, QuesTech, Inc. v Iran.
Iran-United States Claims Tribunal Report, Vol. 9, Touche Ross v Iran (1985) AWD 197-480-1.
Iranian Journal of International and Comparative Law
Volume 2, Issue 2
December 2024
Pages 58-72

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics