Childbearing as a Public Good; Children as Public Goods: Iran’s Legislative Approach

Document Type : State Practice

Author

Ph.D. of Private Law, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Although the era when children were primarily considered as a source of labor for the familyhas largely passed, the procreation of children remains indispensable for societal continuity.Views on children have shifted from characterizing them as the “private property of the family”to recognizing them as a “public good.” While children may not satisfy all the criteria of a purepublic good, it is widely acknowledged that society bears a significant role in the upbringing,education, and, ultimately, the costs associated with children. Nonetheless, although theconception of a child as a personal property of the family has changed, extensive governmentalintrusion into family privacy is similarly not accepted. This article employs a descriptive-analytical approach to examine arguments for and against this perspective, drawing on theoriesof public and socialized goods, with a focus on Iranian legislation. Children, due to their potentialbenefits, such as their future roles as workforce and taxpayers, exhibit characteristics of a publicgood; however, philosophical, legal, economic, and cultural challenges limit this interpretation.Iranian laws, particularly the Family and Youthful Population Support Act (2021) and Article3 of the Child and Adolescent Protection Act (2020), recognize government responsibility andmark a step toward conceptualizing children as public goods. This article posits thatwhetherchildren are characterized as public goods or as socialized goods, an obligation is thereby createdfor non-parents and, consequently, for the state as the representative of the nation, to share in thecosts associated with them.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Aghaei G, Memarzadeh G and Daneshfard K, ‘National Public Good: A Case Study of Social Welfare in Iran and the Alignment of Upstream National Documents with Amartya Sen's Definition of Social Welfare’ (2024) 60 Legal Research 113 [In Persian]

    Baqeri M and Mir Lavasani SM, ‘The International Position of Public Goods in the Distributive Justice Approach’ (2012) 1(2) Private L 1 [In Persian]

    Bou-Habib P and Olsaretti S, ‘Children or Migrants as Public Goods?’ (2023) 72 Political Stud 1

    Di Nallo A and Lipps O, ‘How Much His or Her Job Loss Influences Fertility: A Couple Approach’ (2023) 85 J Marriage & Family 873

    Folbre N, ‘Who Pays for the Kids? Gender and the Structures of Constraint’ (1994) 29(2) Signs 511

    Gheaus A, ‘The Ethics of Parenting’ (2022) 17 Philosophy Compass 45

    Lister R, ‘Children (but not Women) First: New Labour, Child Welfare and Gender’ (2006) 26(2) Critical Social Policy 315

    Olsaretti S, ‘Children as Public Goods?’ (2013) 41(3) Philosophy & Public Affairs 19

    Olsaretti S, ‘Liberal Equality and the Costs of Children’ (2017) 174(1) Philosophical Stud 155

    Samuelson PA, ‘The Pure Theory of Public Expenditure’ (1954) 36(4) Rev Econ & Stat 387

    1. B) Books

    Becker GS, A Treatise on the Family (Enlarged edn, Harvard University Press 1991)

    Cook DT, The Commodification of Childhood (Duke University Press 2004)

    Ferguson S, Women and Work: Feminism, Labour, and Social Reproduction (Pluto Press 2021)

    Folbre N, The Invisible Heart: Economics and Family Values (New Press 2001)

    Hume D, A Treatise of Human Nature (LA Selby-Bigge and PH Nidditch eds, 2nd edn, OUP 1978)

    Kaul I, Grunberg I and Stern MA (eds), Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st Century (OUP 1999)

    McKiernan J, State Intervention in Family Life: Balancing Child Protection and Parental Rights (OUP 2012)

    Olson M, The Logic of Collective Action (Harvard University Press 1965)

    Rakowski E, Equal Justice (Clarendon Press 1993)

    Shields L, Fairness in Child Rearing: A Game Theoretic Approach (OUP 2023)

    Stiglitz JE and Rosengard JK, Economics of the Public Sector (4th intl student edn, WW Norton & Company 2015)

    1. C) Chapters in Edited Books

    Benkler Y, ‘Power and Productivity: Institutions, Ideology, and Technology in Political Economy’ in Danielle Allen, Yochai Benkler, Leah Downey, Rebecca Henderson and Josh Simons (eds), A Political Economy of Justice (University of Chicago Press 2022) 27

    Casal P and Williams A, ‘Equality of Resources and Procreative Justice’ in Justice, Equality, and Constructivism (Blackwell 2004) 150

    Hart HLA, ‘Are There Any Natural Rights?’ in Jeremy Waldron (ed), Theories of Rights (OUP 1984) 77

    Heckman JJ, ‘The Case for Investing in Disadvantaged Young Children’ in Big Ideas for Children: Investing in Our Nation's Future (First Focus 2008) 49

    1. D) Reports and Working Papers

    Islamic Consultative Assembly Research Center, ‘Analysis of Allocated Credit Distribution for Implementing the "Family Support and Youth Population Law" in 2021-2022 Budget Laws’ (Monthly Expert Reports, Serial No 20173, 2023) [In Persian]

    Nussbaum MC and Dixon R, ‘Children's Rights and a Capabilities Approach: The Question of Special Priority’ (University of Chicago Public Law & Legal Theory Working Paper No 384, 2012)

Iranian Journal of International and Comparative Law
Volume 3, Issue 1
June 2025
Pages 222-233

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics